
The End Of The No-Brainer Investing Era
- Podcasts
- Published on 17 Nov 2026 6:00 AM IST
Investors can no longer count on juicy returns from broad-based AI or artificial intelligence bets
On Episode 1035 of The Core Report, financial journalist Govindraj Ethiraj talks to Rajani Sinha, Chief Economist at CareEdge Ratings as well as Rajrishi Singhal, Senior Journalist, Columnist and Independent Consultant.
SHOW NOTES
(00:00) Stories of the Day
(00:50) The End Of The No-Brainer Investing Era
(06:03) Morgan Stanley Puts Out A Fresh Bull Case For India, Says There Is A Case For Rerating
(09:38) Why Higher Wholesale Price Index Numbers Are A Concern This Time
(15:38) Why The 6.5% Interest Rate Mark Is A Jinx In India And For Whom
(23:36) One Trick That Could Help In Your Journey To Becoming A CEO
—
NOTE: This transcript contains the host's monologue and includes interview transcripts by a machine. Human eyes have gone through the script but there might still be errors in some of the text, so please refer to the audio in case you need to clarify any part. If you want to get in touch regarding any feedback, you can drop us a message on feedback@thecore.in.
Good morning, it's Tuesday, the 17th of November, and this is Govindraj Ethiraj broadcasting and streaming weekdays from Mumbai, India's financial capital.
Our top stories and themes…
The end of the no-brainer investing era is here, or rather there.
Morgan Stanley puts out a fresh bull case for India, says there is a case for rerating.
Why higher wholesale price index numbers are a concern this time
Why the 6.5% interest rate mark is a jinx in India, and for whom?
And one trick that could help in your journey to becoming the CEO.
Markets, Oil, Summits and Morgan Stanley
The Wall Street Journal says that the no-brainer era is over. What this means is that investors can no longer count on juicy returns from broad-based AI or artificial intelligence bets.
Instead, they must size up winners and losers and look around corners to spot the risks that can trigger an avalanche of selling. The journal says adding the AI trade is in turn vulnerable from a dizzying number of angles. First, rising interest rates threaten overextended borrowers.
The payoffs from vast amounts of capital spending plus trillions of dollars of off-balance sheet commitments is still hazy or could be far off. Then China's low-cost alternative AI products could undercut US champions. And of course, Democrats have moved into states like Texas, which could mean delays or worse in big data centre projects.
This, of course, is in reference to the recent midterm elections in the United States. Texas accounts for nearly 30% of US data centre capacity set to come online in 2028, representing by far the largest share of any state, a Bloomberg report said last week. And then the crowding of hedge funds into the same bets is itself proving to be a risk, especially on days when they all sell at once, says the Wall Street Journal.
And then the NVIDIA affair. As we discussed in the core report a few days ago, whichever way NVIDIA goes with or without Jensen Huang, events like this do cause investors to pause or rather provide them the luxury to pause and re-look at everything once again. The journal says the volatility, stretching back to the Nasdaq's recent peak on October 6th through the election's aftermath and Jensen Huang's stunning exit as CEO of NVIDIA, has fundamentally rewired the AI trade.
Now, this fundamental rewiring is obviously good news for markets like India, who've lost out because of the AI trade, despite strong fundamentals which have been improving despite everything and more on that shortly. Meanwhile, from record sales, foreign portfolio investors are now clocking record buy numbers. The $9 billion figure we spoke of yesterday is the highest FII net buy figure for a single month.
So with all of this in the background, Indian markets were up again on Monday, with the rally now extending into three weeks thanks to both the inflows from foreign portfolio investors and of course, steady to lower crude oil prices. On Monday, the Sensex was up 510 points to 82,102 and the Nifty 50 was up 146 points to 25,291. The broader market saw the Nifty mid-cap 100 and small-cap 100 falling 0.5% and 1.1% each.
Speaking of crude, prices are still holding above $95 a barrel as of Monday, but the signal to watch is clearly of surplus oil for the first time possibly since the combination of US and Israel attacked Iran on the 28th of February this year, which means there is a strong counter now to war risk, which of course has not gone away. The world oil market will return to a surplus in the fourth quarter of this year, Reuters quoted the International Energy Agency saying on Friday, that's last week, as Middle East exports recover faster than global oil demand despite the continued attacks on shipping on the Hormuz Strait. Speaking of war risk not going away, US President Donald Trump is arriving at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Summit in Shenzhen, China later this week, where he is scheduled to meet with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin.
He comes politically weakened at home and yet perhaps even more eager to flex his power abroad, a Bloomberg report said, adding his weakened position in Washington may simultaneously be pushing him towards an arena where he has more control, high-stakes diplomacy with foreign powers. The president has suffered twin blows in recent weeks that threaten to cloud the gathering of the world's largest nuclear powers, the report said, adding that Republicans' crippling defeats in the US midterm elections and the scandal that cost Jensen Wang his job leading artificial intelligence chipmaker NVIDIA Corp. Trump has sought to deepen relationships with his Chinese and Russian counterparts despite their differences over the West Asia conflict.
Before he reaches China, Trump will be in the Philippines, where India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi has also arrived for the ASEAN India and East Asia summits. There are at least five big multilateral meetings bringing Narendra Modi and Donald Trump face-to-face in Manila before Trump heads to China for that meeting with Xi Jinping and Putin, Bloomberg reported. Now, India is particularly interested in ASEAN-China negotiations over a code of conduct for the waterway through which a large share of global trade passes, the Bloomberg report said, adding as yet, though, no one-to-one meeting between Modi and Trump has been confirmed.
The waterway referenced here is the South China Sea, which Prime Minister Modi has previously described as one of the main arteries of global merchandise trade, with India repeatedly stressing freedom of navigation and adherence to international law. Back home, the Finance Ministry is examining various aspects of capital gains on equities and probable changes in taxation could come in the union budget for 27-28, that's on the 1st of February, according to the Central Board of Direct Taxes Chairman Ravi Agarwal while speaking to reporters on Monday. He said the ministry is considering suggestions from various stakeholders made during pre-budget meetings, the Business Standard reported.
Of course, if flows remain strong as they are, the case for not being very liberal on capital gains taxes for foreign portfolio investors might emerge. But equally, it could be argued that one reason, even if small, foreign portfolio investors are returning is the promise and likelihood of capital gains taxes on them either going away or being reduced sharply. Like we pointed out last week, several international brokerages have put out bullish calls on India right now.
The analysts at Morgan Stanley are back with a new one as well. They say the Indian markets have a case for re-rating and are expecting the Sensex to hit the 95,000 mark by December 27, in their base case scenario, which is up around 16% from the current levels, a Business Standard report said. The 27 BSE Sensex target of 95,000, to which they attach a 50% probability, implies that the Sensex would command a trailing price earnings multiple of 23x ahead of its 25-year average of 22x.
According to them, the premium over the historical average reflects greater confidence in the medium-term growth cycle in India, India's lower beta, a higher terminal growth rate, and a predictable policy environment. Add to this makes robust domestic equity flows, a nascent IPO pipeline, weak trailing relative performance, relative valuations, just-off-all-time lows, and all-time low foreign positioning, and it makes for a compelling outlook for equities, says Morgan Stanley. They also assume that there will be robust domestic growth, steady global growth, a resolution to the India-US trade deal, which of staying below $100 a barrel.
Morgan Stanley says they prefer domestic cyclicals over defensives and externally facing sectors and are overweight financials, consumer discretionary, and industrials.
Strong Corporate Performance
We spoke of strong corporate performance. The BSE 500 profit after tax growth has accelerated to 25% in the second quarter of 2026-27 versus about 17% in the second quarter for 2025-26, according to a report from brokerage MK Securities.
The strength, the report says, was across the board with the Nifty 50 growing 26% and MK's coverage growing about 27%. The top line did most of the heavy lifting. Non-banking and financial services companies' sales growth of about 26% was supported by energy and discretionary, both growing over 30% in the MK basket of stocks.
EBITDA margins had recovered about 250 basis points, quarter and quarter to about 16%, but was 30 basis points lower year on year. Profit growth ran slightly ahead of sales growth with companies outside of the banking and financial services growing their profit after tax at almost 29%. 41% of BSE 500 companies reported BAT above 25% versus 39% in the first quarter of 2026-27 and 36% in the second quarter of 2025-26.
And the share was even higher in the MK universe at 44%. But the improvement was at the top end, the middle thinned out with the 10-25% bucket shrinking to 17% from 23% and about a quarter of companies still reporting a BAT decline. Now here's the interesting part, large caps led a 30.5% growth, followed by small caps at about 26%, mid caps at about 14%.
But this also was the sharpest turnaround of the three, says the report, from minus 3.3% in the first quarter of this year. In terms of sectors, telecoms, utilities, and energy were the positive outliers. In their cases, the profit after tax growth was about 59-69%.
Energy went from a 45% contraction in the previous quarter of this year, but this may not repeat every quarter. Discretionary materials, industrials, and financials were all up, showing healthy growth. IT slowed to about 10% from 15% in the previous quarter.
And interestingly, healthcare was at minus 6.7%, being the only sector to contract, says the report.
Why Higher Wholesale Price Index Numbers Are A Concern This Time
High wholesale price inflation numbers could pressurise companies into increasing their product prices at some point of time, a note from Bank of Baroda researchers said, after latest figures have pegged October WPI at 12.3%. Companies have passed on only a limited part of that input cost increase to consumers, keeping in mind the overall inflation environment. Now, wholesale price inflation is not considered actively while formulating monetary policy.
It is critical when evaluating the input costs for commodity manufacturers, the report has pointed out, and thus reminds us as well. Now, manufactured goods in particular have seen a 9.5% inflation rate, with high inflation rates in textiles, tobacco products, chemicals, rubber products, metals, and electrical equipment. On the food side, pulses saw a 12.6% inflation, with tour having 26%, and the crop is expected to be lower this time, says the report.
In the non-food basket, fibres and oil seeds saw a high inflation of about 28% and 22%, which could be mapped to expected lower output due to sowing patterns as well as end-of-the-season phenomenon. The worrying numbers are obviously in the fuel basket, which has a 14% weight in the index. I reached out to Rajani Sinha, Chief Economist at CareEdge Ratings.
INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT
Rajani Sinha: Yes, high WPI inflation is concerning because as we can see there's a very wide wedge between WPI and CPI currently. So WPI is at 12.3% going by the latest number whereas CPI is at 6.1%. So one that is because WPI is more reflective of what's happening to the global crude oil prices whereas CPI inflation has been kind of contained because the retail petrol and diesel prices have not increased that much. But apart from energy prices the WPI inflation is also showing very high inflation in manufactured products.
So there also in that category we are seeing inflation of around 10%. If you look at categories like metals, chemicals, plastic and plastic products, electrical equipment, high double digit inflation we are seeing in those categories. So the concern is that this very high WPI inflation we could see that percolating to CPI inflation also going forward.
And apart from high energy prices and high manufactured product price inflation that I spoke about, we are all aware of the high food inflation being a cause of concern which is also being reflected in WPI inflation.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Right and going by history what's the usual transmission time and intensity between WPI and CPI?
Rajani Sinha: So there is as such you know we can't look at the past data and be able to infer by when you know it will percolate to CPI inflation and by how much because there are components in CPI inflation currently which are showing very stable inflation. In the sense if I look at categories like education, healthcare, clothing, housing, those components are not showing much inflation. And recreation, so we are not seeing much inflation there.
And if we are talking about high metal prices, commodity prices, those high inflation will not necessarily result in these components of CPI inflation going up. But overall broadly the manufactured product inflation if overall you know food inflation, fuel inflation is so high, input prices are so high, overall it will result in you know inflationary expectations going up, manufactured product inflation going up. And hence we will see some impact on CPI inflation also going forward.
But we cannot draw a direct correlation and I will not be able to tell you as to by how much CPI inflation will go up because WPI inflation is so high. We don't see CPI inflation going up much higher than where it is currently. In fact CPI inflation is expected to peak in the next month and then it's expected to start moderating a little bit because of high base and now also because of global energy prices going down.
So we don't see CPI inflation rising to levels as high as WPI inflation.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Right okay so you've answered my next question as well. So what's the broader outlook now given where we are today and your view on both WPI and CPI particularly for the next few months and your expectations on rate hikes and to what extent?
Rajani Sinha: So like I said for both for WPI and CPI inflation we are expecting it to peak in the next month. So a little higher maybe around the same levels or a little higher than these levels in the month of November. And then we expect inflation to start inching down gradually and that's mainly because of the base effect will start playing out and towards March we will see like say CPI inflation we expect it to go below six percent and WPI inflation we expect it to go to around eight to nine percent by the end of the fiscal year that is in March.
So overall we are expecting that you know the high inflation that we are seeing hopefully it has peaked in this month or maybe the next month. After that we are going to see some inching down of inflation happening but having said that the comforting factor is that hopefully energy you know crude oil prices have gone down and it will stay at lower levels than was the case say two weeks back. But some of the other components of inflation like food inflation that will remain a cause of concern.
We are seeing very high vegetable prices, edible oil price inflation, sugar inflation and not just in India globally that's the case. So those concerns will be there. We are seeing high metal prices you know some of those concerns will also persist.
So broadly inflation will remain high in the next few months but definitely it will start inching down going forward.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Rajani thank you so much for joining me.
Rajani Sinha: Thank you.
Why The 6.5% Interest Rate Mark Is A Jinx In India And For Whom
India is heading back towards interest rates last seen about two years ago, and this time it's getting there against a tougher backdrop, accelerating inflation, rising food prices, and heightened geopolitical uncertainty, a Bloomberg report on Monday summed up. He also said that economists and financial traders expect the Reserve Bank to lift the benchmark rate by another 50 to 75 basis points in coming months, taking it as high as 6.25% from about 5.5% right now. Now, India has seen borrowing costs at these levels before, but what makes this cycle potentially more painful is the combination of oil, which is hovering around $100 a barrel, signs of fatigue amongst consumers and fragile global investor sentiment, a mix that could magnify the hit to growth, the Bloomberg report said.
So, while interest rates are set to rise, could we be heading for the 6.5% jinx? Columnist and journalist Rajrishi Singhal, writing in the Mint newspaper, says that three recent governors of the Reserve Bank of India have exited their position in the last 10 years when interest rates hit 6.5%. Now, this may be a coincidence, but it also hides confusion over what the natural interest rate is, where monetary policy is neither expansionary nor contracting, inflation is stable near the targeted rate and output is near potential, he writes. Sinha also says that this is not to suggest that the level acts like an unofficial policy boundary or that the exits were anything but routine, but 10 years happened to end or were not renewed when rates touched 6.5%. I reached out to Rajrishi Singhal and I began by asking him what made him see this link and more importantly, what it meant looking ahead.
INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT
Rajrishi Singhal: It's an interesting point, you know, so I was looking at the record of all the governors so far in terms of how they've dealt with interest rates during their, you know, tenure in office, and maybe it's a coincidence, but I don't know, but I found that the three of them left office when the rate reached 6.5 percent. I mean, in all cases, it doesn't seem that they were asked to go, but, you know, either their term got over and it was not renewed, or as in Rajiv Patel's case, he left of his own volition in the middle of his own term before his term actually completed, but the 6.5 percent somehow became a benchmark of sorts, and, you know, it became a jinx for governors, and this has only happened in the past 10 years.
We've not seen this trend play out in this manner ever in the past, and so this is particularly noticeable since 2016, so the past decade, and especially, you know, after this government has come into power, we've seen this play out, so I thought we don't know what, you know, is the reason behind it, but I thought it should be put out there in case we get some clarity from somebody, either the government or the RBI on why 6.5 percent.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Okay, and you may never get that clarity, but let's look at what's happening elsewhere. Obviously, right now, there is a clamour for interest rates to be raised, and from the five and a half percent, and you refer to the monetary policy committee's notes as well, so there's a good chance that in the next few months, we will hit that 6.5 percent mark. What else is happening in the economy broadly that could be affected because of these rates or is causing these rates?
Rajrishi Singhal: Very clearly, Bhuvan, energy prices have gone up. There is also a second round effect because of energy prices. Your other product prices have gone up.
Food prices are high, so food and fuel, as you know, in consumer price index constitute about 40-50 percent of the weightage, and so any increase in food and fuel pushes up the inflation rate. Food primarily because of El Nino effect this year, so we've had Karnataka declaring a drought officially. We've had Andhra declaring a drought.
Maharashtra has declared a drought. I think Rajasthan is about to declare a drought officially. State after state is in terrible shape because of deficient rains, poor monsoons this year, and that is pushing up food prices.
Food and fuel combined are pushing up prices, on top of which we're seeing a slight problem of demand in terms of the economy is not creating enough jobs, so wages have been stagnant for a long, long time. On one hand, you have rising prices, and on the other, you have demand which is not really robust, demand from households primarily for consumption, and that in some ways is indirectly reflected in the retail credit numbers where unsecured borrowing from households has been going up, so your households have two, three loans running concurrently at the same time, very clearly then indicating that they're using borrowed money to fund consumption, current consumption, and therefore that kind of indicates that there is stress, income stress for many households. So in that sense, this is slightly dangerous still to be.
So RBI will have to think twice before it actually increases interest rates, but my feeling is they will have to increase interest rates. I don't know how much, but 25 basis points or 50 basis points, but they will have to increase interest rates because GDP growth seems to be on track for 7.2%. So you have high inflation, high growth, and that's clearly untenable. So we're still some distance away from 6.5%. If RBI this December increases rates even by 50 basis points, it still goes up to only 6%. So we'll have to see whether this governor, you know, has brave enough to take rates up to 6.5% subsequently.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Right, and maybe now that he's read your column or potentially read your column, he may think twice. I don't know, keeping my fingers crossed, Movin. Okay, so inflation, as you mentioned, is also now creeping up and we are past the 6% driven by food inflation, which is a large component.
What's the broad macroeconomic mix of signals looking like? I mean, obviously, all of this precipitate change in regulation, regulatory authorities, the people who lead them, and so on. And that's what's happened in the past.
So are you seeing other signals like that, which could, you know, at least potentially trigger change? A couple of things.
Rajrishi Singhal: I think one of the changes that you will see is, I mean, so Reserve Bank, for instance, I don't think they have much to play around with at this point of time. So they are caught in a bit of a cliff stick. They want to keep growth, you know, the growth engine humming, but at the same time, they have to be very, very concerned or anxious about the way inflation is playing out.
So their primary concern, therefore, will be inflation at this point instead of growth. Seemingly, that's my view. And so there will be some kind of tamping down on inflation.
One of the things that they really need to do is they don't know how to deal with all the liquidity in the system. There's a lot of money in the system, which is not, you know, being put to productive uses. It's not building productive assets.
So some of that money is adding to inflation because, you know, there is so much money chasing so few goods at this point of time. And that, you know, pushes up prices. So they will have to reel back a lot of that extra surplus cash that's sloshing around in the system.
How they do it if they have a bunch of tools in their toolkit. So I'm sure they can, you know, they've already started doing open market operations through sale of bonds, government securities. So that's the limited point.
I don't really see if they can do wide sweeping changes to bring about systemic change at this point of time.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Got it. Rishi, thank you so much for joining me.
Rajrishi Singhal: Thanks for having me.
One Trick That Could Help In Your Journey To Becoming A CEO
Executives who are promoted to CEO often share a similar trait.
They demonstrate a willingness to communicate and collaborate with colleagues on quarterly earnings calls, a recent study quoted by the Wall Street Journal has found. Researchers looked at transcripts from about 78,500 earnings calls over a 10-year period from 2010 to 2020. During those calls, the report says about 10,864 executives from about 2,500 public companies answered questions from investors and analysts, and the researchers found that the executives who invited colleagues to jump in and provide perspective or more detail to an answer were perceived by board members and shareholders as being more cooperative and on average, were more likely to become the company's CEO.
Across the sample, only about 6.7% of executives who spoke on the calls were promoted to CEO. On the other hand, executives who regularly invited other colleagues to speak on calls saw a promotion rate twice as high at 13%. A professor at Columbia Business School told the Wall Street Journal that it's that inviting a colleague to speak could signal to analysts, investors, and boards of directors that the executive is good at coordination and communication across the organisation, all of which could reveal meaningful leadership traits, adding that the executives are more likely to be promoted if they interacted with a range of colleagues on calls rather than just one or two.
They also found that cooperative executives were equally likely to invite colleagues to speak on earnings calls whether the company performed well or poorly, or if the question posed by the analyst or investor was difficult or easy to answer. Which obviously suggests that these leaders aren't trying to deflect poor performance onto others, says the professor who spoke to the Wall Street Journal. In fact, the researchers determined that executives who ask colleagues to wane only in response to negative questions are less likely to be promoted than those willing to share the spotlight all the time.
Govindraj Ethiraj is a television & print journalist and Editor of www.thecore.in, a multi-platform business news venture focussed primarily on traditional economy and financial markets. He also founded IndiaSpend.org & Boomlive.in, data journalism and fact check initiatives. Previously, he was Founder-Editor in Chief of Bloomberg TV India, a 24-hours business news service launched out of Mumbai in 2008. Prior to setting up Bloomberg TV India, he worked with Business Standard newspaper as Editor (New Media) and spent around five years each with CNBC-TV18 & The Economic Times. He is a Fellow of The Aspen Institute, Colorado, a McNulty Prize Laureate 2018 & a winner of the BMW Foundation Responsible Leadership Awards for 2014. He is a Member, World Economic Forum’s Global Future Council on Information Integrity, 2025.

