
Making Sense Of Churning Prices
- Podcasts
- Published on 19 Nov 2026 6:00 AM IST
Expect more such days of consolidation, even if the markets were to pick up
On Episode 1037 of The Core Report, financial journalist Govindraj Ethiraj talks to Radhika Rao, Senior Economist and Executive Director at DBS Bank as well as Dhiraj Nim, Economist and FX Strategist at ANZ Research.
SHOW NOTES
(00:00) Stories of the Day
(00:50) Making Sense Of Churning Prices, Across Asset Classes
(03:41) Goldman Sachs Upgrades India To Overweight
(05:13) Societe General Joins Other Banks Setting Up Equity Capital Market Divisions In India
(08:12) Why FPIs Are Returning And What Will Keep Them Here
(17:16) India’s Rupee Is Stronger And Panic Levels Should Be Easing, What Should Be The Strategy Here On
—
NOTE: This transcript contains the host's monologue and includes interview transcripts by a machine. Human eyes have gone through the script but there might still be errors in some of the text, so please refer to the audio in case you need to clarify any part. If you want to get in touch regarding any feedback, you can drop us a message on feedback@thecore.in.
Good morning, it's Thursday, the 19th of November and this is Govindraj Ethiraj broadcasting and streaming weekdays from a slightly hazy Mumbai once again, India's financial capital.
Our top stories and themes…
Making sense of volatility across asset classes.
Goldman Sachs upgrades India to overweight.
Why foreign portfolio investors are returning and what will keep them here?
Societe Generale joins other banks setting up equity capital market divisions in India.
The rupee is stronger and panic levels should be easing. What should be the strategy here on?
Markets, Goldmans Sachs, Societe Generale and India-UK FTA
Now, these are indeed interesting times.
Mature investors chase stocks, not prices. Many seasoned fund managers have told me over the years, including quite recently. But human nature is such that one chases prices, like it happened with gold and silver in the last year.
Against the peaks hit in January of about $5,599 for gold and $121 for silver, the decline is now at about 32% for gold and 62% for silver. Ajay KD says what began as profit-taking has become a test of whether investors can distinguish temporary financial stress from lasting fundamental damage. Of course, most commodity experts we've been speaking to have been and were advising caution when gold and silver were seeing these dramatic jumps in prices.
Obviously, very few listened. Now, the thing is that price rise in silver sounded more defensible because of industrial and non-industrial demand, and gold just seemed somewhat sturdy at its price levels. Because governments are continuously buying gold, and more on that in a moment.
But many Indian investors piled into silver and gold exchange-traded funds or ETFs or asked their advisors to do so. Depending on when they got in, and I'm referring to the last year, they're either looking at losses or very modest gains. Most model portfolios before equities picked up again this month called for a close to 15% exposure to gold and silver alone.
Now, would this argument still hold given that equities are on the ascendant? Veteran fund managers would say yes, because that is the nature of diversification. But those who stuck to equities and were cursing themselves, their advisors, their fund managers, or wealth managers, or their friends who advised them, in the year or last year, would perhaps allow themselves a small smile, at least for now. Meanwhile, stock prices were down on Wednesday as selling kicked in.
Expect more such days of consolidation, even if the markets were to pick up. Markets were at a near nine-month high on Tuesday, and the Nifty 50 and Sensex have risen about 9.4% and 10.2% in November alone and so far, respectively, after foreign portfolio investors have bought a record $10 billion worth of shares. The Sensex fell about 500 points to close at 82,031, and the Nifty 50 was down 159 points to 25,227.
In the broader markets, the Nifty mid-cap 100 and small-cap 100 were down 1.2 and 0.3% each. Among other signals we continue to track, which have a macro impact on India and its overall finances, oil prices were down on Wednesday. Thanks to an increase in U.S. crude and fuel inventories, though, losses were curbed by ongoing U.S.-Iran fighting and attacks on vessels in the state of Hormuz.
Reuters reported adding that Brent crude futures were down to about $91.99 or just under $92 a barrel. Brent crude prices are inching down and are now down about 20% this month, thanks to increased supplies. Which, of course, is good news for India's import bill and the rupee, which closed at Rs.
93.44 against the dollar and more on that shortly. Meanwhile, Goldman Sachs has upgraded India to overweight with a Nifty target of 28,500 by end-2027, led by a 15% earnings growth. The Business Standard reported Goldman Sachs saying that strong domestic demand, robust earnings, and decade-low foreign positioning make India an attractive diversifier against the AI-related trade, and valuations could rise by 7% to 8% in a bull case scenario, whereas they could derate about 10% to 12% in the bear case.
Interestingly, within the Asia region, Goldman Sachs has raised its China H shares, which are traded in Hong Kong to overweight, and lowered Taiwan and China A shares, which are traded in Shanghai, to market weight to balance exposure to AI tech hardware. Back to gold, while silver might be in somewhat free fall, the yellow metal is holding steady, or at least somewhat relatively. One reason is central bank purchases, which appear to be stepping up whenever prices moderate.
Right now at a one-year low, central banks are taking advantage of that correction to ramp up purchases. Official sector buying gathered pace through the second and third quarters, with central banks adding about 321 tonnes of gold in Q3 alone, according to World Gold Council data. The latest purchases were up about 8.5% from 296 tonnes in the previous quarter, and significantly higher than the 57 tonnes bought in the first quarter.
So all of this takes the central bank's total gold purchases for the year to about 675 tonnes, up 6% for the same period last year. The buying spree could continue, says the World Gold Council, and it expects central bank demand in 2026 to at least match the levels seen in 2025. And in a fresh sign that equity markets are looking up here, French bank Societe Generale plans to set up an equity capital markets business in India.
Bloomberg is reporting, adding that the French group is expanding its investment banking operations across Asia. This would allow Societe Generale to compete for underwriting mandates in India, where the IPO pipeline remains strong. Despite two years of record activity, Societe Generale has been around in India from 1978, but operates as a scheduled commercial bank focused more on the corporate banking, trade finance, and forex side, including some investment banking products like structured finance and derivatives.
Bloomberg says India's fundraising boom is attracting more global banks, including Emirates NBD, DBS Group Holdings, which started ECM businesses or equity capital market businesses in the country this year. And we'll have a view from DBS in a moment. Barclays says Bloomberg is also looking to enter that business.
Meanwhile, India has several FTAs or free trade agreements signed up, including with the UK and EU. But the first sign that it may not all be hunky-dory has surfaced. The India-UK FTA is operational as of July 15 this year, so it's been four months now.
Reuters is reporting that India is now imposing an effective duty of 162.5% on bulk Scotch imports, which has apparently jolted liquor firms as the levies exceed the 150% charged before the agreement, according to sources that spoke to Reuters. The India-UK trade agreement that was implemented, as we said in July, halved tariff rates on Scotch to 75%, and businesses in Britain both hailed it as a big win for companies like Pernod Ricard and Diageo, which import Scotch in bulk and blend it to make popular products in India, which has a roughly $65 billion liquor market, according to Reuters. We did discuss this theme with the Global Trade Research Initiative's Ajay Srivastava on Monday, who pointed out, among other things, that India must honour the FTA.
“The AI Leg”
The global economy is on the AI leg, International Monetary Fund Managing Director Kristalina Georgieva said Monday, warning that over-dependence on the sector risks the world's financial stability. Circular financing amongst AI companies, where money invested in an AI company ultimately flows back to the investor through purchase orders, has grown to a little over a trillion dollars, two-thirds of it funded by debt, the IMF estimates. It's not a huge size, but it's a rapid increase, Georgieva told CNBC.
She also said that a sudden drop in investment confidence and withdrawal from the AI field could weaken economic growth. We have a world economy that is standing on one leg on the AI leg. If this leg wobbles, it can lead to financial stability troubles, she warned.
Nvidia Corporation, which has seen more than a trillion dollars wiped out of its market value in the last month, is at the centre of these circular financial deals. The IMF had raised its 2026 global growth forecast to 3.1% in October, as major economies leaned on AI investment to power growth, otherwise curtailed by the energy crunch caused by the Iran war, according to CNBC.
Why FPIs Are Returning And What Will Keep Them Here
Brokerage Goldman Sachs expects the Reserve Bank to raise the repo rate by 25 basis points in December, followed by another 50 basis points in the first half of calendar year 2027, taking the total rate of 6.25% by the second quarter of calendar year 2027, the Hindu Business Line quoted the bank saying.
This interest rate hike is expected to moderate India's real GDP growth to 7.2% in calendar year 2027, down from an estimated 7.9% in calendar year 2026. Now, all of this is broadly in sync with other forecasts as well, most of which are predicting a rise or an increase in December that's next month. Now we've had several macro numbers in the last week, including consumer price inflation, which has crossed the 6% mark thanks to food inflation, rising sharply and wholesale price inflation, which crossed the 12% mark to 12.29%. So what's the composite view of India's macro numbers looking like? And how do we look at foreign portfolio investment flows, which have picked up this month to record levels, particularly in terms of continuity? I spoke with Radhika Rao, Senior Economist and Executive Director at DBS Bank in Singapore, and I began by asking her for her broad view.
INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT
Radhika Rao: I think I would summarise it this way, right? So, inflation, it's been firmer inflation, growth is proving to be resilient, and really the onshore markets have gotten a break. So, what do I mean by that is growth really has kept up quite a strong beat.
In fact, we will have GDP numbers soon, and I think the first half of the fiscal year is looking closer to upwards of seven and a half percent at this point, meaning the first and the second quarter put together. If you see the high frequency prints from everything from credit growth to auto sales to PMI numbers, and all of these have kind of showing you that domestic demand has held up, which includes consumption as well as investments, partly led by the government support as well. And on the trade front, while the import bill has been widening, exports have actually been doing very well, and latest numbers also suggested was the monthly normal value was at a record high.
On the growth front, I would say it's resilience proving to be quite, you know, holding up well, also coming at a time when corporate profitability in general has been picking up. So, that's on the growth front. And if you look at the inflation, inflation has come in a bit stronger than expected, and I think the run is not over yet.
So, the next six months, for example, you would see inflation, the CPI inflation closer to the six percent mark. So, a combination of these two coming at a time when onshore markets in terms of the asset class, especially the currency and the equity markets have entered a favourable price action, especially in the month Got it.
Govindraj Ethiraj: And what explains then the inflows or the sudden rush of flows that we are seeing, particularly in the last 17 days of November, we have now hit 10 billion dollars, which is a record in itself for a single month, and we've not even finished the month. So, what's caused this sudden shift?
Radhika Rao: You're absolutely right. I think it's been fast and furious. You have seen FBI inflows upwards of 10 billion in the month.
The equity index is back at pre-Iran war levels. And you've really seen, I would say, concurrent fatigue in the AI net story, especially in some and then, you know, some pockets of company-specific issues. And at the same time, the bigger elephant in the room, which has been oil prices, it was holding up and not so long ago in three figures, and now we are seeing it come off 20-25 percent from those highs.
I would say concurrent improvement in what were previously headwinds and now have turned tailwinds. I think that has really helped. And that global backdrop has kind of brought the domestic positives into play.
Like we mentioned earlier, corporate profitability has been strong, despite all these headwinds that we have seen in the first and the last two, three quarters. So, there's a general recognition that, you know, entry levels are more attractive at this point. Corporate profits have been doing well.
Yes, I think margins might come under pressure as some of these costs are not passed on. But overall, it's a favourable story with an economy where it's got very strong growth numbers. So, all of this into play, I think, has really lifted the equity, you know, India's equity board story.
And at the same time, you've also seen the rupee appreciate quite strongly. So, even for a foreign investor from dollar index, adjusted dollar-based returns have also become more attractive than they were earlier. I would say a culmination of all of these factors have really been behind a strong shift in the winds.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Right. So, you talked about the concurrent impact of the AI trade diminishing or the fascination for AI may be diminishing slightly. So, do you have a sense today whether it's a short-term phenomenon?
Is it a long-term phenomenon? Is there some sort of mid-path that's emerging? Because we've seen AI trades turn, but also turn back again in recent months.
Radhika Rao: Yeah, I think we should qualify here. And you're absolutely right. You should qualify between the pace at which the AI story and the build-up in the CAPEX story was moving, and because of which the equity markets were faring very well, especially in some pockets of the world, that's slowed down, that's moderated.
I think there is a difference in moderation in this price action and a sharp correction, right? So, a sharp correction spares none. That would, you would really see a very strong shift away from risk sentiments, and that could not really benefit any EM markets generally.
So, what we're seeing now is, I think, a slowdown. It's actually taking stock of the investments that have gone in to see how much of productivity gains have been gathered. And at the same time, also, we're going to see now frontier model, most customer-facing companies now come and list.
And when they do list, it'll be interesting to see what the investors make of it, because some of these companies are still to break into, turn strongly positive. Because if you see the infrastructure players, the chip players, they are more hardware-driven, they're more infrastructure-driven, they've got good profits to show. But as this universe of AI-related companies grows, especially the ones with the frontier model, how are they performing?
I think that'll be a very big gauge how this AI story goes. In all, I would say that what we're seeing now is more of a moderation in that euphoria. I don't think this is a correction.
If this stays in a very controlled, managed fashion, I think we're really going to see some other strong pockets emerge in the region.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Right. And if I were to come back to India, so one of the feelings or projections at that time, which is really a couple of months ago, was that large caps have lost some of their flavour. And we've seen that turning very quickly.
For example, right now, we're seeing a lot of money come back into large caps, we're seeing a lot of money come back into banking, we've seen bank index hit an all-time high. So are you seeing this current flow realigning itself with new themes? Or is it really going back all-in into traditional and well-understood or well-known themes?
Radhika Rao: I think the point of entry usually when there is a sudden gush would be to go to the traditional counters, right? I think financials, space, consumer discretionaries might be another. I think it will take a bit of time for themes to emerge.
But at this point, I think familiar, strong names, companies with strong management, which were available at much more attractive levels, I think has been the first port of call. And you should remember earlier also that foreign money was not completely shunning India, because you were seeing a lot of public issues and private placements where foreign interest was strong. It was just that it was taking away from the secondary markets and you weren't seeing the same amount of enthusiasm there.
So coming back to your question, yes, certainly I would say the first port of call, I don't think is very thematic at this point. It is going to the fundamentals. It is going for safer places to stay, good names at attractive levels.
And if this sustains, then you could make it a much more broader rally story. Because certainly if you see the mid-cap as well as the small-cap indices, counters have also actually produced very good results, double-digit number.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Right. So as you said, the macros are strong in India or relatively strong. The micros are also looking strong.
So is that a good enough case to keep foreign portfolio investment in or would investors expect to see something else or something more?
Radhika Rao: I think at this point, it depends on what the foreigners are looking for. I think there's also a rotational portfolio readjustment rotation that is going on. So it's going beyond the natural habitats, which has been holding up for the past year or so, and looking at other areas.
So I think a lot of things come into play, right? How is the economy doing? It's also doing in relative to others.
What are the names available? Names available relative to others. And of course, on FX-adjusted basis.
So the currency also plays a part. But as of now, I would say certainly the story is attractive. Back to fundamentals really helps.
But we just have to be watchful of a few things that could turn, where tailwinds could become headwinds, which is a reversal in some of these developments, particularly geopolitics, particularly oil. Because we're seeing a kind of a tentative calm. It's not been resolved.
But markets are able to take in some intermittent shocks. But any reversal of these could bring in a return to price action becoming much, much softer. So yeah, we are in a place where relative calm is good.
And it allows the investors to take a look at the broader picture and reallocate accordingly.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Got it. Radhika, thank you so much for joining me.
Radhika Rao: Thank you so much.
India’s Rupee Is Stronger And Panic Levels Should Be Easing
The rupee closed nearly flat on Wednesday, reversing course from a seven-month high hit in early trade, thanks to a firmer dollar, which offset the tailwind from robust. The rupee closed nearly flat on Wednesday, reversing course from a nearly seven-month peak hit in early trade, thanks to a firmer dollar. The rupee closed at Rs.
93.44 per dollar, compared with its previous close of Rs. 93.47. The rupee is facing some resistance, but this time it's from a very strong dollar, where the dollar index has risen 0.2% to 103.8, its highest since April 2025. Now, all of this is because markets are preparing for faster rate increases by the US Federal Reserve in light of upbeat economic data and hawkish commentary.
I reached out to Dheeraj Naim, Economist and Forex Strategist at ANZ Research, and I began by asking him whether we were past the point of panic, which we had seen in previous months, and we're now looking at a more stable rupee.
INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT
Govindraj Ethiraj: Dhiraj, thank you so much for joining me. So I'm picking up on the rupee and its relative strength in recent days and we've closed at about 93.44 on Wednesday and this seems to be despite a fairly strong dollar. Now my larger question is to start with, are we now or rather are we past the point of panic which clearly seemed to be driving some of the responses or policy responses in the last few months?
Dhiraj Nim: Right, so I think I mean it's maybe unfair to sort of call it panic to the extent we understand that you know the fundamentals of the economy were very strong even to begin with in this entire episode of rupee weakness. It was really in a way a market feature why the rupee weakened so much and the RBI was responding to that market feature. We can you know delve into those details if you like but essentially the last 10 or 11 days we have received about 1 billion dollars on an average in equity inflows which is a substantial tailwind to the rupee and has caused it to rally you know but we have to sort of look at it against what's happening globally because the fault lines for the rupee were actually global, they were not local right. So I think the most important feature is the oil prices have heftily declined after the US midterms the outlook for the US Iran war has improved if not resolved and that has led to a complete you know decline in oil prices from about 100, 500, 10 dollars a barrel to about 90 dollars a barrel now and a large part of rupees rally in my mind has to do with that. Another concurrent development has been a bit of a fracture we have seen in the AI trade.
I'm careful to say AI trade and not the AI sector because the continues to do well but there has been a lot of crowding into that AI equity market trade and after the US midterms for various reasons and various developments the outlook for the AI trade has also somewhat dimmed from the levels that we were seeing before that and it was well known that since India has not been a major player in this AI trade so far for the reason because of which it was losing so much money it became a natural hedge and some of this money may have come in from that source also. So while it is right to say that the rupee may be past the point of maximum weakness I would still be cautious to say we are completely out of the woods and that's for three reasons. The first is our trade deficit has widened a lot and you know it can remain wide and it's not just because of oil that's the thing to be mindful of.
The second is the other global forces for example the elevated cost or the elevated interest costs interest rates and yields globally they remain very much a cause of concern and if anything then the US monetary policy tightness could be more than we were expecting let's say a couple of weeks ago. And the third is you know while the Reserve Bank of India's measures to curb import demand import hedging demand have worked quite well and we can see that in the hedging data they have not yet been able to break the exporters hedging jinx. So when we're looking at the 13 days data into November over 13 days into October the exporter hedging has also declined and I think once that turns around we can be a little more certain that the rupee is on a more solid footing.
Also remember that the Reserve Bank of India is meeting the oil demand from their own reserves at the moment. If they were to put it back to the interbank market the rupee would not be at 93 59 340 it would perhaps be closer to 95. So think of the true value of spot closer to 95 at the moment if we were to include the oil demand in the interbank market.
So a lot of moving parts there I understand but certainly I think it's safe to say that we are perhaps past the peak of maximum weakness but that is a combination of what's happening globally and how rupee remains heavily under the influence of policy.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Right so let me pick up on the dollar to start with you know if we were to look at the way the rupee was responding in the last year I mean I say last year I literally mean 2025. The dollar used to be the major driver and then the war started maybe had the tariff war which led to a real war and then oil prices started impacting the rupee as you just pointed out. Now if you were to look ahead what could be the major factors that one needs to look out apart from the somewhat let's say the sudden developments or the sudden events like an escalation in war and so on.
Dhiraj Nim: So I think look the last one and a half year or so one thing that we have noticed in the financial markets is typical correlations have completely broken down and that could remain in play even now so the dollar strength for example right now could be weighing on a currency like the Indonesian rupee but not so much on the rupee was rupees benefiting from let's say underweight positions of foreign investors that had been selling a lot of Indian assets before.
The fact that India is a natural hedge in the anti-AI play so to speak and how the decline in oil prices just sort of brightens up the macro outlook a little bit more. I think all of that sort of is behind why correlations look broken but going ahead I think there is an absolute need to track two set of factors. The first is of course fundamentals.
I think oil prices remain very central to this story because the energy markets outlook may have improved a bit but when you look at the fundamentals of supply and demand they do not tell you that energy markets are out of the woods yet. I mean the shipping through the Strait of Hormuz is no more than half of what it used to be in the normal times right. The global strategic reserves are down substantially will need replenishment if anything global growth is so resilient that demand may remain strong for oil.
So some of these factors continue to tell that a decline in oil prices will have a floor. So that's one. The second is what's happening in US in terms of the bond yields the long-term bond yields and the monetary policy.
The outlook is a little bit more hawkish there now than it was let's say two weeks ago. And the third of course is what's happening to the AI trade. So these factors will remain dominant from an external perspective.
But domestically from a financial market perspective from the rupee market perspective I think we really need to see how exporter and importer hedging behaviour develops from here on. Like I said if the exporters come back into the market to hedge that really will be a very strong indication that the rupee could be on a more solid footing from here on. So far I don't see a lot of signs of that happening and that's probably because everybody is waiting to see if this spate of equity inflows is here to stay or will it whittle down or what will happen to this.
So we have had 11 good days. Would it become two months or three months? You know we will have to see.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Right. By inference one would assume that we were somewhat concerned when the rupee was 97 98 and seemingly heading towards 100. And obviously there were interventions at that point. At current levels are we comfortable because after all we've also seen record exports and exports would have or could have benefited to some extent from a weaker rupee.
So the question really is that where do you think policy would like rupee to be in the near term so that it fulfils the need of exporters who are trying to or striking good bargains against our obviously higher import bills assuming oil stays around $90 a barrel.
Dhiraj Nim: So this is something we've written about in our research and it's important to realise that given strong economic fundamentals that is a growth is strong market profit growth is strong inflation is more or less contained in a core inflation sense if not headline. Our current account deficit is still very tame. I mean despite oil prices where they are we're still forecasting about 1.2% of GDP kind of a current account deficit for this year. So against this set of indicators the way policymakers think about the rupees fair value is that should not have depreciated to 97 or close to 100. After depreciating whatever 10 15 percent it did over 2025 it was absolutely unwarranted for the rupee to depreciate even more right. It is against that thinking that they intervened so heavily including via regulatory curve.
Now it is hard to say where they see the rupees fair value to be but in my head the problem is that when everybody expects the rupee to weaken the people who hold the dollars don't convert them and the people who demand the dollars demand even more which is what we were seeing among importers and exporters in terms of the hedging behaviour. This is not normal of course and against this abnormal behaviour is where the RBI was intervening heavily through its routine interventions in spot and forward markets as well as the regulatory curves right. So right now what they're doing is that letting the rupee appreciate.
In fact they're capping the upside in USD INR quite actively even on some days now they're still selling dollars into the market to keep USD INR on a bit of a downtrend in the hope to elicit a certain behavioural change from importers and exporters. So this sort of tells you that we could see some more appreciation in the rupee flows continue to come in till the RBI is sure that the kind of behaviour that aligns with the one one and a half percent of GDP kind of current account deficit is there in the market and is there to stay. They will continue to remain in the market.
Govindraj Ethiraj: Right that's a good note to end on. Dheeraj thank you so much for joining me.
Dhiraj Nim: Thank you very much.
Govindraj Ethiraj is a television & print journalist and Editor of www.thecore.in, a multi-platform business news venture focussed primarily on traditional economy and financial markets. He also founded IndiaSpend.org & Boomlive.in, data journalism and fact check initiatives. Previously, he was Founder-Editor in Chief of Bloomberg TV India, a 24-hours business news service launched out of Mumbai in 2008. Prior to setting up Bloomberg TV India, he worked with Business Standard newspaper as Editor (New Media) and spent around five years each with CNBC-TV18 & The Economic Times. He is a Fellow of The Aspen Institute, Colorado, a McNulty Prize Laureate 2018 & a winner of the BMW Foundation Responsible Leadership Awards for 2014. He is a Member, World Economic Forum’s Global Future Council on Information Integrity, 2025.

